Mel Kiper Jr. Highlighted 15 underrated NFL draft prospects in his annual favorites list, emphasizing traits like work ethic and football IQ over consensus rankings.
Kiper favors players who embody hard-nosed football values
The ESPN analyst clarified that his list of favorite prospects is not a projection of draft order or talent evaluation but a personal selection based on film study and intangibles. He values players who demonstrate toughness, high football IQ, and a love for the game — qualities he believes translate to NFL success regardless of draft position. Kiper noted that several of these players may not be selected until Day 3 of the draft or might proceed undrafted.
Payton and Johnson stand out at quarterback and running back
At quarterback, Kiper praised Payton for his three-year wait behind Cam Miller at North Dakota State before becoming the starter in 2025, during which he completed 72% of his passes for 2,719 yards, 16 touchdowns, and four interceptions. He also highlighted Payton’s rushing ability — 777 yards and 13 touchdowns last season — suggesting he could be used in a Taysom Hill-type role by NFL offensive coordinators. Kiper projects Payton as a fourth-round pick.
For running back, Kiper pointed to Johnson’s 2025 season with Nebraska, where he rushed for 1,451 yards on 251 carries (fourth in the FBS) and added 12 touchdowns. At 5-foot-10 and 202 pounds, Johnson is described as a compact, explosive runner who forced 93 missed tackles — third nationally among FBS backs. Kiper also noted Johnson’s receiving production — 85 catches for 656 yards and five touchdowns over two seasons — making him a viable three-down back. He projects Johnson as a third- or fourth-round selection.
Why does Kiper separate his favorites from his official Massive Board?
Kiper distinguishes his favorites list from his top-150 Big Board to highlight players he personally enjoys watching and believes embody the right makeup for football, even if they aren’t consensus first-round talents.
Could these prospects still have NFL careers despite lower draft projections?
Yes, Kiper emphasized that many of the players on his favorites list — though likely Day 3 picks or undrafted free agents — possess the toughness, intelligence, and work ethic that NFL coaches value, suggesting they could still earn roster spots and contribute.